Why Indian D2C Startups Struggle: How to Build Sustainable Growth?
- Jasaro.in
- Jul 22
- 6 min read
Only 10 D2C consumer startups have hit the ₹600 Crore revenue mark!
In a nation of 1.4 billion people, with a startup ecosystem boasting over 90,000 startups, only a handful of direct-to-consumer (D2C) brands have managed to cross this revenue milestone.
Imagine, just 10 startups i.e. Mamaearth, Boat, Veeba, Atomberg, Wakefit, FirstCry, Lenskart, Country Delight, Bluestone, and Curefoods have hit the ₹600 Crore revenue mark.
Why are Most D2C startups Struggling in India?
Especially when our middle class is expanding and spending more than ever before?
The answer isn't a lack of ambition or ideas. It's a lack of discipline. Too many promising brands are built on shaky foundations, chasing vanity metrics while ignoring the fundamental principles of sustainable growth.
Let's dissect why so many D2C startups get stuck, and more importantly, what founders can do to build a sustainable, profitable venture.
The Great Illusion: Chasing Revenue or Real Product-Market Fit?
You often heard (more apparently in 2020 - 2022) many founders proudly shouting on LinkedIn on extravagance funding rounds, followed by massive top-line revenues. The numbers are very impressive, however, as you dig deeper, that's when the picture gets ugly.
The startups are spending ₹400 Crores in marketing (high Ad-spend) and heavy discounts to barely generate ₹100 Crores in sales.
This is like a vanity project funded by venture capital, referred to as "Push-based Growth."
Push-based Growth
Push-based Growth is when you are constantly "pushing" your product onto the market through aggressive ads, deep discounts, and endless promotions. However, the moment you turn off the marketing spend, your sales plummet. You've high customer acquisition costs (CACs) but even higher churn. It's a financial disaster waiting to happen.
What Real PMF Looks Like: The Power of Pull vs. Push
Product-Market Fit (PMF) is one of the most overused and misunderstood terms in the startup world. It's not about how many customers you can buy (or acquire). It's about how many customers you can retain i.e. customer retention. Real PMF is when your customers become your best marketing channel. If you've to perpetually scream to be heard, you don’t have a fit; you just have a loud voice and deep pockets.
Pull-Based Growth
This is the holy grail. It’s when the market actively "pulls" your product from you. This manifests in several key ways:
High Repeat Purchase Rate: Customers come back again and again without needing a 50% off coupon to be convinced.
Strong Organic Demand: A significant portion of your traffic and sales comes from direct searches, word-of-mouth referrals, and organic social media.
Low Customer Churn: People stick around. They become subscribers, advocates, and part of your community.
The Unit Economics Litmus Test
Forget Gross Merchandise Value (GMV) for a second. Let’s talk about Contribution Margin. In simple terms, for every product you sell, are you making money after accounting for all the variable costs associated with it (cost of goods, shipping, payment gateway fees, performance marketing)?
A healthy business model is reflected in its unit economics. A key metric every D2C founder should be obsessed with is the LTV:CAC ratio i.e. Customer Lifetime Value to Customer Acquisition Cost.
A healthy D2C business should aim for a ratio of at least 3:1.
This means for every ₹1 you spend to acquire a customer, they should generate at least ₹3 in profit for you over their lifetime. If your ratio is 1:1 or less, you're effectively paying customers to take your product. That’s not a business; it's a charity.
The Growth Trap: Is Your Scale-Up Plan a Ticking Time Bomb?
Let’s say you’ve found genuine PMF. Customers love your product. Your unit economics are solid. Now it’s time to hit the accelerator, right?
Hold on. Scaling isn't just about pouring more money into what works. Real, sustainable scale tests every single component of your business. Growth exposes all the hidden cracks in your foundation, and if you’re not prepared, it will break you, sooner than expected.
Are You Building on Bedrock or on Burn?
There's a seductive shortcut in the D2C world: buying growth. Instead of painstakingly building a superior product, a seamless customer experience, and a trustworthy brand, many founders take the easier path of aggressive customer acquisition.
This approach often leads to a fragile business. Your supply chain, built for 1,000 orders a day, snaps when you suddenly get 10,000. Your two-person customer service team is overwhelmed, leading to negative reviews that poison your brand reputation. Your margins, already thin, evaporate under the pressure of scaling operations.
If your operations aren’t ready for a 10X increase in demand, your growth will collapse under its own weight. The brands in the ₹600 Crore Club understood this. They invested in warehousing, logistics, technology, and talent before they scaled-up, not after. They built a solid bedrock of operational excellence that could support the weight of their ambitions.
Beyond the Digital Bubble: Distribution is Still King in India
As a digital-first entrepreneur, it's easy to believe that Instagram ads and a slick Shopify website are all you need. That's a dangerously narrow view of the Indian market.
"Digital-first" should not mean "digital-only."
Tapping into the Real India
India is a continent-sized market with incredibly diverse purchasing habits. While a 24-year-old in Mumbai might discover your brand on Instagram, a 35-year-old in Lucknow might first encounter it at her local supermarket. A family in a Tier-3 town still relies on the advice of their trusted kirana store owner.
The reality is this: a massive portion of Indian commerce happens offline. If you are not present in the places where the majority of India transacts, you are leaving an enormous amount of money on the table. This means:
Modern Trade: Getting shelf space in retail chains like Reliance Retail, D'Mart, or Big Bazaar.
General Trade: Partnering with distributors to reach millions of mom-and-pop kirana stores.
Specialty Stores: Placing your beauty product in neighbourhood salons or your health food in local gyms and pharmacies.
Quick Commerce: Integrating with platforms like Blinkit, Zepto, and Swiggy Instamart, which have become the new digital kirana for urban India.
Lenskart and FirstCry are perfect examples. They started online but realized that a physical presence was crucial for building trust and scale. Their stores are not just sales channels; they are experience centers that solidify their brand in the customer's mind.
The Cardinal Sin: Ignoring Category Discipline
Here’s a common mistake I see: founders applying a single playbook to a diverse portfolio of products. They treat a ₹3,000 recliner, a ₹200 gourmet sauce, and a ₹40,000 diamond pendant with the same marketing strategy, the same sales funnel, and the same success metrics. This is a recipe for disaster. Each category has its own unique DNA.
Understanding Your Category's Rhythm
a. The Recliner (High-Ticket, Low-Frequency)
The Customer Acquisition Cost (CAC) will be high. The buying cycle is long and involves deep research, comparisons, and possibly a physical trial. Trust is paramount. Your marketing should focus on education, detailed specifications, glowing testimonials, and a rock-solid warranty. The goal is a single, profitable sale.
b. The Sauce (Low-Ticket, High-Frequency)
The CAC must be extremely low. This is an impulse or a routine purchase. The game here is about availability (distribution is key!), taste, and repeat business. Success is measured by purchase frequency and basket size. You win by becoming a staple in the customer's monthly grocery list.
c. The Diamond Pendant (High-Ticket, Emotional)
This purchase is driven by an occasion, a birthday, an anniversary, a milestone. It's a high-consideration, emotional decision. Marketing must build aspiration, trust, and a sense of luxury. Authenticity certification, elegant packaging, and storytelling are more important than a discount code.
Ignoring these nuances is like trying to use a hammer for every job. You might get it done, but it will be messy, inefficient, and ultimately, it will break. Successful founders are masters of their category. They obsess over the specific psychology, purchase drivers, and path to loyalty for each product line.
Conclusion: Build for Meaning, Not Just Momentum
In the age of social media and 24/7 news cycles, it's easy to get caught up in the chase. Chasing funding rounds. Chasing headlines. Chasing the temporary high of a viral campaign. This is momentum. But momentum is fleeting. It’s the sugar rush that inevitably leads to a crash. What you should be building is meaning.
Meaning is built through boring discipline. It’s the relentless focus on product quality. It’s the consistency of your brand's voice. It’s the conviction to say "no" to a bad-margin sales channel. It’s the patience to build customer relationships over quarters and years, not just a single campaign.
The brands in the ₹600 Crore Club aren’t just big; they are, for the most part, building it right. They understand that in the consumer world, scale is a marathon that requires stamina, patience, and an unwavering commitment to the fundamentals.
So, as you build your venture, I urge you to look beyond the vanity of top-line revenue. Ask yourself the tough questions:
Is my growth driven by genuine customer pull?
Are my operations strong enough to handle success?
Am I meeting my customers where they actually are?
Do I deeply understand the unique playbook for my category?
The goal isn't just to get big. The goal is to build a business that lasts. Let that be the real benchmark for success.
Found this article insightful; please help others to discover it by liking, sharing, and commenting below.
Comments